Magic Ring Won't Close: Troubleshooting Tips

Sterling Silver Nordic Rune Ring, Rune Wedding Band, Magical Jewelry
Sterling Silver Nordic Rune Ring, Rune Wedding Band, Magical Jewelry from


Knitting and crocheting are wonderful hobbies that allow us to create beautiful and intricate designs. However, sometimes we encounter challenges, such as a magic ring that won’t close. This frustrating issue can prevent us from continuing our projects and achieving the desired results. In this blog post, we will explore some troubleshooting tips to help you overcome this problem and ensure a successful closure of your magic ring.

Understanding the Magic Ring

The magic ring, also known as the magic loop or adjustable loop, is a technique commonly used in crochet and amigurumi projects. It allows you to create a tight and seamless center for your work. However, due to various factors, the magic ring may sometimes fail to close properly, leading to loose stitches and an unfinished look.

1. Tension Matters

One of the main reasons why a magic ring won’t close is incorrect tension. If your tension is too loose, the ring will not tighten properly, resulting in gaps and an unstable center. Ensure that you maintain consistent tension throughout your work, especially when creating the initial loop and pulling it tight.

2. Needle Size and Yarn Weight

The needle size and yarn weight you choose can also impact the closure of your magic ring. If you’re using a larger needle with a thinner yarn, the stitches may not tighten enough to close the ring completely. Consider adjusting your needle size or using a thicker yarn to achieve a firmer closure.

3. Technique Adjustment

Review your technique when creating the magic ring. Ensure that you’re following the instructions correctly and pulling the yarn tightly after each stitch. Sometimes, a minor adjustment in the way you hold the yarn or the tension applied can make a significant difference in the closure of the ring.

4. Stitch Count Check

Double-check your stitch count before closing the magic ring. If you have added or missed stitches, it can throw off the balance and prevent the ring from closing smoothly. Count the number of stitches required in the pattern and make any necessary corrections before proceeding.

5. Reinforce the Closure

If you’re still struggling with closing the magic ring, you can reinforce it by using a slip stitch or a few extra stitches through the center. This extra reinforcement can help secure the closure and prevent it from opening up during your project.

6. Practice Makes Perfect

Remember, mastering the magic ring technique takes practice. Don’t be discouraged if your first few attempts don’t yield the desired results. Keep practicing, experiment with different yarns and needle sizes, and soon you’ll become proficient in creating perfectly closed magic rings.


Encountering a magic ring that won’t close can be frustrating, but with the right troubleshooting tips, you can overcome this challenge. By paying attention to your tension, needle size, technique, stitch count, and reinforcing the closure, you’ll be able to create beautifully closed magic rings for your future knitting and crocheting projects. Remember, practice makes perfect, so keep honing your skills and enjoy the wonderful world of crafting!

Read more